Jun 21, 2011

The new Fighting Module vs. the old one by Eike

Share:

The recent (most likely accidential) rollback of the new fight module gave me the opportunity to run some research about the acceptance of the module.
In the last weeks I've heard complaints about the new fight module from many people. Some just say it sucks, some say they've heard that it sucks and some just complain that Brawler is not working.

I've had it since a few days after it was released, so I had a lot of time to test it and have seen a lot of improvements and bugfixes that Zynga has made during that time. I have really learned to love it and cannot understand the complaints about it. Let me check the most-heard complaints:
- "Brawler does not work!!!!"
Give Arun some time to update it, or switch to the Assassin-a-nator. It does not yet have full functionality from Brawler, but we're fast in adapting, and this is going to be a great tool.
- "Its slow!!"
Actually it is not. I've tested it on two accounts, one with and one without. The first fight page (the so called "popup") takes exactly the same time to load like on the old Module (1.3s). But, and here comes the great part...Every subsequent call is much faster, because the whole page doesn't get reloaded, only the results. It's great!
- "But its a popup!! I hate popups!!"
Actually, it's not a popup at all. You can configure it to "dock", then its above the fight list just like the old module was. It is just a different layout than the old one.
- "I cannot see the used items"
Yes, you can. They hide below the enemy picture where it says "more info...".
- "But it is new, and I hate new stuff"
Don't worry, that is only human.
- "All the targets are iced!"
That is not a problem of the new fight module, in fact, both modules use the same fight list. It's a general problem, that has nothing to do with the fight module.

I'll stop here, I guess there are more complaints about the fighting module, but I guess it's nothing that Zynga could not work on. And they will, they really did a great job listening to the PAC and others who gave their  constructive criticism about the fighting module.
I have asked the players on the MWLL Fan Page who had the new module and were switched to the old one, which they liked better. And guess what, most of them love the new one (11 vs. 3 in my count). And the few who prefer the old one just had the above reasons: Too slow, not Brawler compatible. And on other places like the board I see the same. Also in my German MW-Family, 100% like it.

So, my shoutouts: 
To everyone who doesn't have the new fight module yet: Don't let yourself be influenced by the few people with the loud voices. There are enough people who like the module, although it's a change and most people consider changes as bad.
To those who have the new fight module and don't like it: You will get used to it, and it will become better. And better. Don't worry!
To Zynga: Thanks, you have done a great job. Please go on with that and don't despair. There are enough people who love your new module.



Article written by Eike from the Team Spockholm and co-writer to the MW Loot Lady Blog
All material is protected by copyright law


22 comments:

  1. i had the new fight screen for awhile too, and i will admit i hated it at first. my main reason being the whole change thing. i am a creature of habit...lol. but then last night, they switched me back to the ''old'' one again (WHY?? I D K??!!) and now, i know for sure, i hate the ''old'' one! i sure hope i get the new one back, again!! very soon!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I just want to say that it looks like Z also improved the OLD fight module: Making subsequent attacks on the same person feels much faster than it used to be -- I can rapid-click and it attacks multiple times, just like the Hitlist does.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I got the old one back last night. I hate it. I want the new one back. I loved it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I got the old one to back last night. I hate it. And I also want the new one back. dang zynga dont they know that its unpleasant to play jojo with theirr players, for sure i have a chat later on.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I loved MANUALLY fighting with the new module, something I just don't care for with the old one. I want the new one back!
    Even now, running Brawler, which is nice, but I got to use the Assassin-a-Nator a few times and it showed a LOT of promise. Once Healing in chosen city is there.. BAM! It becomes fantastic.

    But now, I am really missing the NEW Fight Module :(

    ReplyDelete
  6. I want the NEW Style back!!!

    FINALLY Zynga got something right!
    I have over 5 million fights won and well over 100K ices, and the new fight style is better than the old one 1000%!

    New style finally got rid of the screen bounce, accidental Ask Mafia to attack, and jumping back to the fight screen in the middle of fighting someone...

    And the addition to the health meter and the "get revenge" were awesome additions!

    Seems the only ones who did not like it were the ones who ran Brawler 24/7...

    Zynga don't listen to the haters! listen to the people who actuality fight and play the game...

    ReplyDelete
  7. i havent this new module....

    ReplyDelete
  8. i just got the new one, the only thing i dont like about it is you cant see how many xp points you have left before you level up

    ReplyDelete
  9. New One Is Back for me. Thanks Zynga n Great Work. ;)

    ReplyDelete
  10. new fight module drop 5x loot items in Brazil too?

    ReplyDelete
  11. I just got it and it was like Christmas morning! I love to see my opponents health drop as I attack the crap out of em! I was never a huge fight fan and I don't have mega ices but that is gonna' change!I run FF and this sucker is fast! I busted through 1500 stamina and was never bored!!Maybe they did do something right this time!If ya don't like it sorry don't use it ,I will and look forward to kicking you ass!Poison(US)Heatwave look forward to keelin'ya!!!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I just got the new one today,, Fantastic, well done Zynga (for once)..
    And the Assassin-a-nator, also brilliant..thanks Spockholm, another excellent job....

    ReplyDelete
  13. I just want the old one back =(

    ReplyDelete
  14. I got the old one back last night. I hate it. I want the new one back. I loved it.

    ReplyDelete
  15. old fight works better, new fighting if you have over 4k health and actually spend money on the game ... it sucks. You can't move onto another person after ice'n one, if you are in a war and you ice one person chances are your dead before you go to the next one after all the load times and waiting for it to catch up ... health checking by attacking once is so time consuming it makes the game unlivable. To everyone who complained about cc players, most will leave cause of this ... they game is now yours again.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Guess I made my last Brawler run this morning, currently using the Assinator and after some setting tweaks I started getting loot and ices. Watched the first "revenge" attack on someone that had stolen an ice. Don't see what the big deal is, it fights the other player, loot drops, and ices are happening. Seems faster than Brawler was too. No complaints and big thanks to the script writers!!

    ReplyDelete
  17. and it's fluctuating between 2.80-2.90 exp/stam!!

    ReplyDelete
  18. hate it hate it, want old one back, it bounces all overr the place and u cant tell whats happenig, hate ices being robbed that sucks
    tried for 2 days to ice 2 more to get the bug, i was slaughter each an everytime cause it was toooo sloooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooow
    yes I SAID ITS TOOOOOOOOOOOO SLOWWWWWWW

    ReplyDelete
  19. AND BRAWLER STALLS OUT, ASSANATOR STALLS OUT NOTHIGNN WORKINGWITH EITHEER ONE,,,,

    ReplyDelete
  20. new fight page was not too slow for me at all. I Lkie the health meter and get revenge feature. I can not give it a full opinion though as Ifired up assassin-n-nator soon after I gave the new layout a few fights and like where assassin-n-nator is headed. already it has the fun of seeing stolen ices being revenged and that is sweet. Took 1,000,000 BRL from one guy who stole an ice :)

    ReplyDelete
  21. The new fight module FUCKING SUCKS!!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete

Comments are moderated and will not be published until they are reviewed. Please don't use bad language or insult others. For faster feedback on questions, visit our fan page.